Connect with us

News

Pandora Papers And The Paradox Of A Propaganda

Published

on

 

By Bala Ibrahim.

It is no longer news that few weeks ago, the media space was filled with the report of a global investigation, that exposed the alleged offshore hideaways of some of the world’s most powerful people. Under the name, The Pandora Papers, and carried out by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists, ICIJ, the project was said to have sieved through nearly 12 million confidential files, that revealed how some people, including high profile Nigerians, flout extant laws and legislation.

What may be new is the contradictions in the reports, alongside the perceived purpose of the project, and the motive behind the propaganda, especially where some people were unfairly accused of seeking to conceal their financial dealings, by setting up shell companies to warehouse large assets in illegal jurisdictions.

Through misconceptions, factual mischief, crafty and deceitful methods of putting out reports, the propagandists aim at silently and skillfully smearing the names of some people, living and dead, with the Abacha family evidently amongst the targeted dead. It is sad that even death, and after over 20 years in the grave, some people wouldn’t allow Abacha to sleep in silence.

BREAKING: Truck Carrying Diesel From Bunkery Kills Prominent Chief In Edo

This article intends to look at the journalistic jiggery-pokery used by some colleagues of the pen profession, to wrongly rope in some people in underhand dealings, by giving insights into some of the facts that have been muted deliberately in the propaganda, especially the lies to smear the name of the Abacha family, using Governor Bagudu of Kebbi state, as a sitting duck.

The report of the mischief in the Pandora papers began thus, “Eleven years ago, Abubakar Bagudu, the current governor of Kebbi State, then a senator, dispatched a delegation to Singapore in search of a new haven to shelter his controversial wealth, which is a target of ongoing forfeiture proceedings by the United States Department of Justice.

The propagandists say the huge funds, warehoused offshore, is part of billions of dollars Mr Bagudu helped the Sani Abacha family to steal from Nigeria in the 1990s. Mr. Bagudu’s choice of secrecy provider in Singapore was Asiaciti Trust, an entity notorious for helping clients hide behind opaque offshore trusts to launder dirty money across borders”.

Investigations have shown that this is untrue, and in addressing the contradictions in the story, and also in order to particularly absolve Governor Bagudu from the framework of these fabrications, I would start by publishing the response of Bagudu’s UK lawyer, to one of the enquiries from Mr. Begley, a foreign media editor, viz:

Dear Mr. Begley.

Thank you for your email of 21st September 2021. Mr. Bagudu has had similar enquiries from Premium Times of Nigeria and the Guardian and it may be convenient for you to liaise, since there seem to be some shared misconceptions and factual errors.

Your questions rest on a premise that there is something illegal or nefarious about the Blue trusts or the monies they hold, and that AsiaCiti were in some sense complicit in underhand financial machinations. This is incorrect and in fact the trusts, the assets they hold, and the interests in both, have been disclosed to the Federal Republic of Nigeria and the authorities in the UK, where the monies have been held, for at least 22 years, at least 11 years before any involvement of AsiaCiti.

Advert

All monies held by the Blue Family Trust are lawfully held, following settlement of disputes with the Federal Republic of Nigeria (“FRN”) during the Presidency of President Obasanjo. Even before that, the fact of those holdings, their location in the UK and their ownership has been known to the FRN and/or the UK authorities from (at the latest) 1999 to date.

To the extent that the settled disputes concerned allegations of corruption against Mr Bagudu, those are, and have always been, denied. It should be noted that there are no findings of any wrongdoing against Mr Bagudu, either civil or criminal, in any jurisdiction, nor has Governor Bagudu been indicted by the United States.

Between 1999 and 2003, there was extensive civil litigation and investigations, including in Nigeria, the UK, Jersey and Switzerland, concerning allegations of corruption relating to certain transactions from the period when General Sani Abacha was Head of State of Nigeria.

Mr Bagudu reached a compromise with the FRN in 2003 (“the Settlement”) by which all claims against him and his family were ended and the FRN received cash and certain rights with an approximate value of $300m. This was in addition to the more than $750 million that Mr Bagudu assisted the FRN to recover immediately following the death of Gen Abacha.

The Settlement was executed with the express authority of President Obasanjo of Nigeria, who provided a signed confirmation that could be produced to third parties, to confirm that the Settlement resolved and released all claims and liabilities of any kind (civil, criminal, or regulatory) that might exist against Mr Bagudu and his affiliates (defined to include certain individuals and entities associated with Mr Bagudu and his family).

The Settlement was the subject of an Order of the English Court. It was implemented with the consent of the relevant English authorities, being the National Crime Intelligence Service (NCIS, subsequently replaced by the Serious Organized Crime Agency (“SOCA”) and the National Crime Agency (“NCA”). NCIS was informed of the allegations that had been made by the FRN, the settlement reached with the FRN and their permission was sought for the transfers, on behalf of Mr Bagudu and related parties and the legal professionals involved. The Settlement was carried into effect with the cooperation and assistance of the Jersey, English and US authorities.

Further, the existence of the trusts were disclosed to the Code of Conduct Bureau in Nigeria by Governor Bagudu and he has at all times complied with all his obligations under Nigerian law. All the circumstances of the monies held and how they were owned had in any event been known to the FRN since 1999.

Your queries to Mr Bagudu suggest that you believe that there is some revelation or surprise about the Blue trusts and their assets or how they came to exist when in fact they are assets that have not moved in more than 22 years, or are fully disclosed and held with the express agreement of the Federal Republic of Nigeria”.

From the foregone submission, it can be seen that the paradox of the Pandora papers, as it affects Governor Bagudu, was foregrounded in the paragraph that reads, “The settlement was executed with the express authority of President Obasanjo of Nigeria, who provided a signed confirmation that could be produced to third parties, to confirm that the settlement resolved and released all claims and liabilities of any kind (civil, criminal, or regulatory) that might exist against Mr. Bagudu and his affiliates.”

If indeed there was a settlement, to which the then presiding President of Nigeria, in the person of Olusegun Obasanjo, provided a signed confirmation, it would be mischievous, malicious and malevolent, to change the narratives to contemplate something illegal or nefarious.

The intent of the Pandora papers is undoubtedly similar to that of the Panama papers of 2016, which exposed offshore companies linked to a number of politicians in Nigeria, that sparked outrage across the country, calling for probes and prosecution of the prominent Nigerians mentioned in the shady deals, but none of the alleged violators was found culpable or guilty enough to be sanctioned.

However, unlike the Panama papers, the Pandora papers has come with a peculiar bias of intentional impairment of the truth. And late Abacha and Atiku Bagudu are two of the targets intended for incivility.

There seems to be a grand design to even question the integrity of President Muhammadu Buhari, who has time without number, doubted the allegations levelled against late Abacha, and whose regime has been working assiduously to recover all looted monies within and without.

Two of the major responsibilities of journalists are upholding the truth, through verification and unbiased reportage. If findings in the Panama papers could not hold waters because of the failure to fulfil such responsibilities, the same fate awaits the Pandora papers, whose revelations are not only contradictory, but condescendingly contemptuous.

News

Northern APC Youths Reject Tinubu’s Second-Term Bid, Form Anti-Tinubu Forum

Published

on

 

A group of youths within the All Progressives Congress (APC) from the 19 northern states has announced its withdrawal of support for President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s second-term ambition ahead of the 2027 general elections.

The group, operating under the banner of the Anti-Tinubu APC Northern Youths Forum, said its decision was informed by what it described as the Federal Government’s failure to address insecurity, economic hardship, unemployment, declining educational standards and other challenges confronting Nigerians, particularly those in the northern region.

The Secretary of the forum, Comrade Umar Chanji, announced the group’s position while addressing journalists in Kano, alongside other leaders representing various states across northern Nigeria.

Chanji, who spoke under the leadership of the forum’s Chairman, Alhaji Mustapha Tinubu, said the group was no longer interested in supporting or promoting President Tinubu’s re-election campaign in the 2027 presidential election.

He said the decision, which was taken under the theme *Gaskiya Dayace*, followed what he described as several unfulfilled promises and the failure of the current administration to adequately address the challenges facing ordinary Nigerians.

Explaining the reasons behind their decision, Chanji identified insecurity as one of the major concerns, arguing that the protection of lives and property, which he described as the primary responsibility of government, had not been adequately guaranteed under the Tinubu administration.

He alleged that several communities across Katsina, Sokoto, Zamfara, Niger, Plateau, Nasarawa, Benue, Kaduna, Kebbi, Bauchi, Taraba, the Federal Capital Territory, Kwara and Kogi states continued to experience attacks, killings and destruction of property.

The APC youth leader further alleged that insecurity had forced thousands of residents out of their communities, disrupting farming activities, education, commercial activities and other means of livelihood.

On the economy, Chanji criticised the removal of fuel subsidy and what he described as the introduction of unnecessary taxes, arguing that the government’s economic policies had increased the financial burden on ordinary Nigerians.

Advert

He also questioned the Federal Government’s handling of the country’s refineries and its promises concerning the introduction of Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) as an alternative to petrol, insisting that the economic difficulties facing citizens had continued despite government assurances.

The forum also expressed concern over the state of education in northern Nigeria, alleging that insecurity had contributed to the disruption of schooling and deprived many children of access to quality education.

Chanji accused the Tinubu administration of using northern youths as political instruments during the 2023 general elections, only to abandon them after securing political power.

He claimed that members of the group played significant roles in mobilising support and promoting the APC’s presidential campaign during the last general election but had subsequently been sidelined in the distribution of political appointments and government opportunities.

The forum’s secretary further accused the administration of promoting nepotism, alleging that political appointments and government opportunities were concentrated among individuals close to those in power rather than being distributed based on competence, loyalty and contributions to the party.

On healthcare, Chanji expressed concern over what he described as inadequate government attention to medical services, particularly for economically disadvantaged Nigerians who struggle to access affordable healthcare.

He also accused political appointees of prioritising personal interests and the accumulation of wealth over projects and policies that could improve the living conditions of ordinary citizens.

According to him, the forum was particularly dissatisfied with what it described as the attitude of some political officeholders who, rather than addressing the concerns of party members and the electorate, were allegedly waiting for campaign funds ahead of the 2027 elections.

Despite withdrawing support for President Tinubu’s second-term ambition, Chanji clarified that the group remained committed to the APC and would continue to support the party’s candidates contesting other elective positions across the 19 northern states.

He said the forum would continue to mobilise, campaign for and support APC governorship, senatorial, House of Representatives and State House of Assembly candidates in the region.

The group, however, urged APC members, particularly youths at the federal, state and local government levels, as well as other residents of northern Nigeria, not to support President Tinubu’s second-term bid in 2027.

Chanji also called on the national leadership of the APC, led by Professor Nentawe Yilwatda, to pay attention to the grievances of party members and address concerns over governance, political appointments and the welfare of ordinary Nigerians.

The announcement marks a growing expression of dissent from within the ruling party, although the extent of the forum’s membership, its organisational structure and the level of support it commands across the 19 northern states were not independently established.

The group concluded its address by thanking journalists and participants who attended the Kano briefing, while reaffirming its commitment to what it described as the struggle for better governance and improved living conditions for Nigerians.

The statement was signed by Comrade Umar Chanji, Secretary of the Anti-Tinubu APC Northern Youths Forum, under the leadership of its Chairman, Alhaji Mustapha Tinubu.

Continue Reading

News

Atiku to INEC: Subject AI Election Result System to Independent Audit Before 2027

Published

on

 

By Yusuf Danjuma Yunusa

Former Vice President Atiku Abubakar has called on the Independent National Electoral Commission to subject its proposed Artificial Intelligence system to an independent audit before deploying it for processing results in the 2027 general elections.

Atiku said the use of AI in election result management without adequate transparency and safeguards could undermine public confidence in the electoral process, particularly if algorithms were allowed to delay, reject or interfere with the transmission of polling unit results.

He asked the electoral commission to disclose the technical and operational details of the system, including its source code, training data, discrepancy-detection criteria and the identities of its developers and third-party vendors.

The former vice president made the demands in a petition addressed to the INEC Chairman on behalf of the African Democratic Congress and allied democratic stakeholders.

In a statement issued on Thursday by the Director of Strategic Communication of the ADC Presidential Campaign Council, Phrank Shaibu, Atiku said independent cybersecurity experts, political party representatives and civil society technologists should be granted access to the system for a comprehensive audit before the nationwide mock accreditation exercise scheduled for November 28, 2026.

He expressed concern over INEC’s announced integration of AI and intelligent document processing into the process linking its Data Verification and Authentication System with the INEC Result Viewing portal.

According to him, Nigerians should be informed about how the technology works and its role in election result management.

Advert

“INEC cannot ask Nigerians to trust a system whose rules they are forbidden to see. If an algorithm can flag a polling unit result sheet, the public deserves to know what triggers that flag, who set the threshold, who can change it and what happens to the result afterward,” he said.

Atiku said technical limitations, including poor lighting, unfamiliar handwriting and worn-out paper, could cause legitimate result sheets to be flagged or delayed.

He argued that such difficulties should not be grounds for withholding valid election results and called for discrepancies to be treated consistently across polling units.

The former presidential candidate also asked INEC to establish and publicise a procedure for reviewing results flagged by the AI system.

He said the commission should explain who would review such results, how decisions would be documented, how political parties would be notified and how erroneous assessments could be challenged.

Atiku said AI should serve only as an administrative tool under human supervision and should not be allowed to delete, alter or permanently block election results.

He also asked the commission to reaffirm the legal status of Form EC8A, the polling unit result sheet completed and signed by presiding officers and party agents.

“The polling unit result sheet, Form EC8A, records what happened where the people voted. INEC must publicly reaffirm the legal status of the physical form completed and signed at the polling unit, and explain how it will resolve any conflict between that document and an AI assessment.

“A machine’s verdict cannot be allowed to quietly displace the evidence witnessed by voters and party agents,” he added.

The ADC presidential candidate called for real-time monitoring access for political parties through a dedicated dashboard or observer interface to enable them to monitor result flagging, upload delays and blocked submissions during elections.

He urged the National Assembly to summon INEC’s leadership and its Information and Communication Technology Directorate to explain the system’s design, safeguards and independent audit arrangements.

Atiku also called on election observers and international partners to include the digital handling and transmission of results in their monitoring activities.

He advised voters to document results as announced and displayed at their polling units to provide records for comparison with electronically uploaded results.

The former vice president linked the demand for transparency to his campaign’s promise of an affordable life, saying Nigerians should be allowed to determine their political future without technological interference.

Continue Reading

News

Trump, Putin, Xi Urged to Translate Historic Trilateral Meeting into Concrete Action to End Wars

Published

on

 

By Yusuf Danjuma Yunusa

Media Diplomacy Studies (MDS), a research and policy advocacy organisation, says the historic trilateral meeting between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping must produce concrete actions towards ending ongoing wars.

The three leaders met on Thursday in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.

In a statement issued after the meeting, MDS commended the leaders for embracing direct diplomatic engagement at a particularly consequential moment in international relations.
The organisation urged them to translate the Shenzhen engagement into resolute, practical and measurable initiatives aimed at securing immediate de-escalation, negotiated ceasefires, humanitarian protection and sustainable political settlements in conflict-affected regions.

Advert

“The world needs fewer theatres of war – if any at all – and more enduring platforms for dialogue, trust and international cooperation,” Mkpe Abang, MDS founder and chief executive officer (CEO), said.

A readout of the meeting published by Chinese state broadcaster CCTV said Xi, Trump, and Putin exchanged views on a wide range of issues, including global energy flows, nuclear proliferation and the international legal system.

However, the document did not mention key issues, such as wars in Ukraine and Iran, artificial intelligence (AI), or the Nvidia scandal.

MDS also said Africa must not remain a peripheral participant in international discussions whose outcomes profoundly affect its security, economic development, political stability and future prosperity.

Abang said media organisations must also recognise their responsibility to promote international peace, particularly at a time when global influence is increasingly exercised through information, narratives and strategic communication.

Continue Reading

Trending